If Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu keep Jingzhou together, can they keep it?

There is a classic saying in the Three Kingdoms, that is, great events in the world must be combined for a long time and divided for a long time. Therefore, I think that Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu should be sent to defend Jingzhou, and it may not be able to defend Jingzhou in the end, because this is the general trend of the world and cannot be changed by two people. Moreover, Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu are not as magical as those written in the romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Judging from the situation at that time, Zhuge Liang was Liu Bei's strategist, and it was impossible for Liu Bei to let Zhuge Liang guard Jingzhou. Otherwise, Liu Bei's stronghold, Shuchuan, will be in a state where there is no military adviser available, because that place is Liu Bei's lair. Moreover, Jingzhou was originally borrowed by Liu Bei. He should have returned it to Sun Quan out of emotion and reason, but he didn't, so Liu Bei has occupied a disadvantage in people's hearts.

In fact, Guan Yu didn't lose Jingzhou because of carelessness. It was because he went out to attack Coss that he gave the home front to Sun Quan and gave Lv Meng a chance. But imagine that if Guan Yu doesn't take the initiative to attack, he just sticks to Jingzhou. How long can he last until he is out? At that time, Cao Cao's army and Sun Quan's army will attack him together, and I don't think he can stand it.

He went out to attack Coss because he wanted to solve Cao Cao's side first, and then he came back to deal with Sun Quan, but nothing could be good for you. You can think of Cao Liu and Cao Cao.

Not only that, there are no reinforcements from Liu Bei here in Jingzhou. Most of his troops are in Sichuan, and in case of war, it is impossible to have reinforcements to support them quickly. This is an embarrassing situation where there are no soldiers available. It's no use sending someone to guard them.