Ask if most of the Chinese medicine practitioners you are sick are quacks?

Many so-and-so experts with Chinese medicine practice certificates may also be liars.

Let me cite a few Chinese medicine colleagues who have been engaged in * * * for many years as examples. They also graduated from the University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, majoring in Chinese medicine, and obtained the qualification certificate of Chinese medicine practice. After graduation, several students followed the hospital's western medicine thinking for several years, then transferred to administration, and some went directly to engage in Chinese medicine business after internship. Some go abroad for further study, others continue to take postgraduate studies and doctoral studies, and take the road of academic research.

I'll just talk about those examples that finally entered the clinic.

Several students are like this. He found that pediatrics was hot, so he declared himself an expert in pediatrics, but he may not have studied pediatrics seriously or used its prescriptions seriously. He used to be only engaged in business or management. The only foundation of pediatrics is the part on the theoretical level of pediatrics in university textbooks.

So I began to do pediatrics in those years. At first, many parents came to register because of the large demand, but slowly, because of the poor clinical effect, after several years, fewer and fewer patients were seen. Finally, I had to find other ways to make money.

Later, he suddenly found that cancer patients have a high income. Patients also listen to me more. So, I began to write an introduction, saying that I specialize in cancer.

Note that in fact, such Chinese medicine doctors are very common in the market, not a few. The reason may be greed, or they may not love Chinese medicine from the beginning. What is even more frightening is that some practicing Chinese medicine practitioners who graduated from Chinese medicine majors do not believe in Chinese medicine themselves, but only hope to get a legal "cheat" signboard (Chinese medicine practitioner qualification certificate).

In this way, a few years have passed, and I have not studied, studied and accumulated experience seriously in these years. Then I recently saw this friend, who is now a gynecologist.

This situation is very sad, not only for doctors themselves, but also for patients who believe in Chinese medicine and trust it. This kind of Chinese medicine doctor has a large proportion in the market, especially in the top three hospitals. Because some top three hospitals have a subdivision (division) model of Chinese medicine, and top three hospitals have medical insurance, it doesn't matter if the curative effect is not good, so people come because there are too many patients in top three hospitals. This mechanism can easily lead to quack, because there is no competitive pressure. Generally speaking, there are many good Chinese medicine practitioners in private Chinese medicine clinics. Although the registration fee is much more expensive, he will spend a lot of time chatting with you and observing your appearance. Generally speaking, private Chinese medicine clinics that can survive must have clinical effects. This is the operation of market elimination mechanism. In private Chinese medicine clinics, quacks can't live. However, in the top three hospitals, it's lucky to send a few papers and mix titles, or plug some money to get some fame. Maybe I can get a master's degree in Chinese medicine. This third-class hospital system is a hotbed for raising Chinese medicine quacks.

If you want to see Chinese medicine, it is recommended to find a Chinese medicine doctor with good curative effect in a third-class hospital, otherwise you should spend as much money as possible to find excellent Chinese medicine doctors in private clinics. If you want to see western medicine, just find a third-class hospital. Because western medicine pays attention to standardization and proficiency, each kind of western medicine is equivalent to artificial intelligence, and there are not many things that need overall thinking and speculation. Almost everything has a set of strict standards in operation. But Chinese medicine tests people's overall thinking ability, vision, observation ability and so on.

Words for colleagues in traditional Chinese medicine

Each of us should take a warning from this issue and not become a grandiose country.

Don't say that I studied Treatise on Febrile Diseases. I studied Chinese medicine, but some people studied it. These big words are useless. What is useful is that you can clearly identify the disease to the patient, optimistically know why it is good, and if it is not good, you can also know why it is not good. The development trend of the disease is beyond your expectation. If you don't know what you don't understand, just admit it truthfully. Don't pretend you don't understand China slang.

If you give it to the patient,

As a patient, it is not easy to tell whether the other person is a quack or a good doctor. Most Chinese medicine practitioners in the market are not satisfactory. Otherwise, the evaluation of Chinese medicine will not be so bad.

Several key points to be grasped in the identification of traditional Chinese medicine;

1. See if the other party has faithfully observed your appearance and shape (visit).

2. When looking at the other person's consultation, the core of the consultation is around the healthy qi of the human body or around your symptoms. (dialectics of internal qi or dialectics of pathogenic qi)

3. See the doctor's own cultivation and spirit. A good doctor must be partial and generally relatively gentle. The spirit will not be too bad. Only those who have rich internal skills can achieve a good mental state and a relaxed body and mind. This is very important.

Other considerations:

1. Don't assume that young Chinese medicine practitioners have no experience and will not be able to cure their own diseases.

Don't be confused by the title of doctor and the huge registration fee. High registration fee and expert title may not have good curative effect. The key is the first three core diagnostic points I mentioned. Of course, a good Chinese doctor must have a good reputation and a huge demand for outpatient services. If you want to judge the quality of a doctor in China before seeing a doctor, you can only ask about the number of outpatients and patients.

3. The topic is just a label, always looking for each other's dialectical thinking and their own ability and quality. Title, which university you graduated from, and who you studied with are of course very important, especially when you know that the other person is a trusted Chinese medicine student (such as Mr. Ni and Mr. Li Ke). But I still have reservations. Even if doctors are confident and grandiose in describing their prescriptions (such doctors are likely to be vain, so you should be careful of such exaggerated doctors), you should also be careful of some Chinese medicine practitioners who try to confuse patients, and forcibly interpret the causes of symptoms or perfunctory patients with industry slang. In the end, we should take our own promotion and comfort as the premise. For clinicians, the cure rate is king. Curing the disease is king.

4. It is absolutely uncertain that an old Chinese doctor is not necessarily an excellent one. Now, even the so-called masters of traditional Chinese medicine, the clinical cure rate is very low. My teacher told me that one of his colleagues (a girl) is a family of Chinese medicine practitioners, and her father (an old Chinese medicine practitioner in his seventies) once treated Chairman Mao and Premier Zhou. Outsiders regard her father as a doctor, but he knows that he is not a god, because the leader took my medicine because of his illness. He doesn't know how to be good, and he doesn't know why he is not good. He dare not tell anyone, but he can only tell his daughter. It happened that she told my teacher, and my teacher told me.

If you can do the above 7 points, you will basically not be cheated by professional Chinese medicine practitioners, or as a patient, you can at least take less detours. Find a suitable doctor or an excellent doctor as soon as possible.