Who caused the difference between "Marshal Ma" and "Marshal Ma"? Why is there a gap in the word-of-mouth of the three "Ma Dashuai"?

In this special festival, I believe many people will revisit the previous classic dramas, among which Zhao Benshan's "Ma Dashuai" series is also one of the options. After all, this drama also led a wave of ratings in that year, not to mention a famous vicious person in northern Liaoning, Fan Debiao.

Zhao Benshan has made many TV series, such as Hao's The Length of a Village and The Length of a Township, Liu Laogen's Liu Laogen's series, and now the third one is out, and Ma Dashuai's trilogy. Of course, the most ruthless is Wang Dana's "Country Love" series, and there are not more than a dozen in one breath.

The author thinks that the first season of Hao's The Length of a Village, the first two seasons of Liu Laogen and the first three seasons of Country Love are all Zhao Benshan's classic masterpieces, and the first season of Ma Dashuai is also among the classics, but the word-of-mouth of the two sequels is slightly poor. Now think about it, in "Ma Dashuai", the audience may remember Fan Debiao or Vanderbilt most.

There are two problems. One is why the first part of "Ma Dashuai" is far more popular than the two sequels. Douban score also verified the existence of this phenomenon. The first score was 8.2, the second score was only 6.5, and the third score rose to 7.3. The other is Fan Debiao and Ma Dashuai. Who made who?

Ma Dashuai 1 has a much better reputation than the two sequels. I think there are at least four reasons:

1, "Ma Dashuai 1" is a complete story in itself, which can completely exist independently from the two sequels. The image and course of each character are also complete.

We saw Ma Dashuai, from looking for his daughter to going to town, to encountering all kinds of sad things, and finally got a relatively satisfactory result by relying on reality.

Fan Debiao, from the chef to Emoko, suddenly woke up and returned to the place where her dream began after experiencing various incidents of pretending to be X and hitting her face.

Ma Xiaocui experienced a love affair that was not vigorous but full of twists and turns. It is also a perfect stage from escaping marriage and falling in love to being moved by general manager Wu.

Mr. Wu, the kind boss, never changed his infatuation and really won back the beauty.

Yu Fen finally got together with Ma Dashuai after a nightmare marriage.

Almost every main character's experience is completed in stages, so "Ma Dashuai 1" looks like a happy ending, and the audience looks very happy and comfortable.

The two sequels obviously belong to the works of dog-tailed mink, and the starting point of their own creation is to inherit the good reputation and ratings of the first one. If you want to make a sequel, you must break the staged happy ending of "Ma Dashuai 1". This kind of "destruction" itself has an unpleasant side, so the reputation of "Ma Dashuai 2" has dropped sharply.

Interestingly, it is precisely because of the poor reputation of Ma Dashuai 2 that the revised Ma Dashuai 3 is equivalent to a low starting point and a rising reputation, but it is difficult to reach the height of the first one.

2. The characters are reasonable and the people are United.

Although the characters in "Ma Dashuai 1" are as eccentric as Brother Biao, they all exist within the reasonable range of characters' behavior, and the cause and course of each person's behavior are reasonable. Even if Fan Debiao is such a tiger, it is also a true portrayal of the hearts of many small people, and it is a positive psychological subconscious.

However, the characters in Master Ma 2 are somewhat much ado about nothing, especially, the paranoia in the works and the neurotization of General Wu. Although there are reasons, they are generally blackened.

The biggest failure was to join Ping Li, played by Quiet. This role is extremely abrupt, and the emotional line is even more inexplicable. Therefore, the word-of-mouth of the second film has not unexpectedly collapsed.

Although there are no black original characters in "Ma Dashuai 3", some inexplicable characters are added to deliberately create conflicts, such as Tang Xiao, a mental derangement. Actually, it doesn't matter if you delete this character.

3. Reflect the reality and have a harmonious ending.

There are many scenes involving the police in Ma Dashuai 1, and there are also many things that the judiciary can intervene but cannot do. For example, Niu Er defeated Yu Fen. But from Ma Dashuai 1, we rarely see that these things can be handled legally, but they are all solved privately.

This is not untrue, but a true portrayal of some 18-line small counties in those days. Therefore, although some plots in "Ma Dashuai 1" seem to be very wronged, there are rules to follow. The ending is also very harmonious, and the people-oriented plot development makes the ending look smooth.

On the other hand, the two sequels are overkill in plot design. In order to pursue harmony, there are some very abrupt plots.

4, funny classics, in line with the law

"Ma Dashuai 1" has two funny points, one is of course Fan Debiao, and the other is Ma Dashuai himself.

Ma Dashuai, played by Zhao Benshan, belongs to the kind of cold humor, playing dumb or really stupid, which makes people laugh through dramatic plots. Even if he is miserable, you will think it is a comedy, and Ma Dashuai will be very lucky.

This ingenious plot design is much less in the two sequels. On the contrary, Ma Dashuai once became a sad and melodramatic figure, making the audience look less relaxed than the first one.

Relatively speaking, Fan Debiao's jokes in "Ma Dashuai 1" belong to the typical "X-face" type. Because brother Biao's appearance is very scary, his appearance is very big, his language is in place, not to mention his style, so putting X on his face is particularly enjoyable.

In the two sequels of "Ma Dashuai", Brother Biao is still the same brother Biao, but the funny way has changed and it has become a "face-saving and painful life". Because there is no previous style bonus, this kind of comedy is somewhat distorted, which makes the audience laugh and also produces sympathy.

Therefore, the author thinks that "Ma Dashuai 1" is more like an inspirational drama in the category of light comedy, while the two sequels belong to soap operas in the urban-rural fringe, adding some funny elements. This difference is also the root cause of the huge difference in word-of-mouth in the trilogy of Ma Dashuai.

Speaking of the first vicious person in northern Liaoning, Brother Biao has now become the darling of the internet, and his image power has already surpassed that of "Ma Dashuai" and become a social and cultural symbol.

There is a saying that I don't know when it is inappropriate. When each of us looked in the mirror in the morning, we suddenly found that we were actually Fan Debiao.

So, between such a hot emoko and Ma Dashuai, who has fulfilled who?

The author thinks that although "Ma Dashuai" shaped Fan Debiao, it also made Fan Debiao exist outside the protagonist Ma Dashuai in the play. But Fan Debiao still emphasized something other than the TV series "Ma Dashuai".

In other words, if Fan Debiao is taken out to play "Ma Dashuai", the bright color of this TV series will be much dimmer, even if it is a solo performance, it is difficult to have this effect.

Therefore, Fan Debiao can be regarded as Fan Wei's personal re-creation based on the TV series Ma Dashuai. It is better to say that "Ma Dashuai" made Fan Debiao's figure, and Fan Wei made Fan Debiao's soul. On the other hand, Fan Debiao made Ma Dashuai unforgettable for a long time.