Huang Hao is just a eunuch. Should he be responsible for the demise of Shu Han?

The Eastern Han Dynasty perished because eunuchs were in power. At the same time, eunuchs did a lot of bad things in order to crack down on political enemies, such as the disaster of parties. Eunuchs artificially identified some aristocratic men as party member and excluded their right to participate in politics. Until the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, eunuchs killed the current general He Jin, which led to a big exchange of fire among consorts, gentry and eunuchs, and finally made the Eastern Han Dynasty court a puppet in name only, and then died.

After the establishment of the Three Kingdoms, Wei, Shu and Wu all learned the lesson of the demise of the Eastern Han Dynasty and strictly prohibited eunuchs from interfering in government affairs. For example, Wei legislated to prohibit eunuchs from interfering in government affairs, and Wu did not experience eunuchs' troubles until his demise. As the only three countries, Liu Chan, the last emperor of Shu Han, did not learn from the demise of the Eastern Han Dynasty. However, in just over forty years, he made the same mistake as the Eastern Han Dynasty. This can only say that Emperor Liu Chan was incompetent.

Historically, Huang Hao should be a eunuch about the same age as Liu Chan, because as early as Dongyun, when he was a waiter and warrior corps commander, he often accused Huang Hao. At that time, Bo Huang was also passive to Nuo Nuo, and did not dare to have any resistance or conflict. At this time, during Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, Huang Hao should be a little eunuch specially selected by Liu Bei to accompany Liu Chan. Liu Chan was a eunuch in 2 1 year.

During the reign of Zhuge Liang, Liu Chan was severely punished. Although it is not in line with the feudal etiquette to govern the monarch with ministers, it is also to make Liu Chan on the right path and hate the feeling that iron does not turn into steel. Look at Wei Mingdi Cao Rui. He was almost at the same time. He came to power at the age of 22, but it was already a political career. Cao Rui is a strategist. He can manage the whole state of Wei in an orderly way. On the other hand, under the strict discipline of Zhuge Liang, 22-year-old Liu Chan hardly had any.

This is the ability gap, and it is also the gap between people. This shows that the ability of Liu Chan is far from that of Cao Rui. Even after Zhuge Liang's death, he was still in power in Liu Chan, and Liu Chan's ability was less than one tenth that of Cao Rui. Therefore, Liu Chan is not a still stupid king, but an incompetent king.

If there is anything that can prove Liu Chan's incompetence, it is Liu Chan's reuse of eunuch Huang Hao. Is Bo Huang capable? No ability. Is it honest? Dishonest. He is just a sycophantic eunuch. With years of affection with Liu Chan, he embarked on the road of politics. What's even more outrageous is that when General Jiang Wei sent the information about the change of Wei's border to the court, Huang Hao had to rely on divination to decide how to deal with this information. This is all from the Three Kingdoms, and it was decided by divination thousands of years ago. Did Huang Hao live thousands of years ago?

The way a country handles important information depends on divination and witchcraft, which shows how serious, incompetent and ridiculous corruption is in this country. Can this country not perish?

Although Jiang Wei was the commander-in-chief of the national armed forces, he still had no right to mobilize troops without the approval of the imperial court, which was a taboo in ancient times. Jiang Wei can only report the information of Wei border to the court and the emperor according to the procedure, and then the court and the emperor discuss how to deal with this information. At that time, Jiang Wei learned that Wargo was training troops at the border, and Wei had a large-scale military mobilization, so he speculated that Wei would have a large-scale military action against Shu and Han.

Jiang Wei's judgment is not wrong. What is wrong is the way the ruling court handled this matter. Therefore, Huang Hao was the first responsible person for the demise of Shu Han.

Because he didn't handle the previous information correctly, he didn't notice that Wei might attack or even deceive the monarch and officials. Huang Hao used divination and witchcraft to tell the emperor that the enemy would not come, but he actually believed it, Liu.

The trust of Zen in Huang Hao was obviously not formed in one day, but a long process. Liu Chan did not investigate the source and correctness of the information, nor did it investigate how Huang Hao handled it. So he believed, so Liu Chan was the second responsible person for the destruction of Shu Han.

Liu Chan's biggest mistake was to appoint an incompetent villain like Huang Hao. Birds of a feather flock together. We can see the level of Liu Chan from the employment in Liu Chan. Zhuge Liang once explicitly told Liu Chan to kiss the gentleman and stay away from the villain, while what Liu Chan did was to kiss the villain and stay away from the gentleman. Strangely, Shu Han will not perish.

So, why did Liu Chan trust eunuch Huang Hao?

Because Huang Hao was the closest person to accompany Liu Chan from childhood to old age. Liu Chan was emperor, Huang Hao was eunuch, and Zhuge Liang, Jiang Wan, Fei Yi and Dong Yun were in power. They all taught Liu Chan the correct way to govern the country. For example, Liu Chan wanted to give Dona several concubines. Dong Yun tried to persuade him, but Liu Chan gave up. For example, Liu Chan wanted to visit the palace, but Zhuge Liang explicitly refused, so Liu Chan was very depressed in the palace.

Liu Chan was a young man when he was emperor. If young people are not interested in power, they will be interested in other things. Obviously, Liu Chan's interest is not in state affairs, and he was suppressed by Zhuge Liang, Jiang Wan, Fei Yi and Dong Yun. Liu Chan naturally got close to his little eunuch, Huang Hao, who was often criticized by the ruling quartet at that time, so they were in the same boat and got closer.

Plus Hao Hao is a eunuch, and naturally he is an apple polisher and flatterer. He kept putting in a good word for Liu Chan and hugging Liu Chan. For Liu Chan, the four political parties in power are inherently indifferent. Only the little eunuch around him is kind to him. In the long run, Liu Chan has great trust in Hao, and even the affairs of state will be handled by Hao Huang Hao.