Do you think it is beneficial to open books? Why?

Now, with more and more books, more people begin to join the torrent of reading. Everyone naturally realizes that there are so many books, which should be read and which are not suitable for us for the time being. This has led to a debate about whether "opening books is beneficial" or "opening books is not necessarily beneficial". Today, our class had a little debate on this. On my left is the representative of Party A, whose view is that "opening books is beneficial"; On my right is the representative of Party B, whose view is that "opening books is not necessarily beneficial". Let's warmly welcome the representatives of both sides to the stage. (Applause) Our appeal is: "It is beneficial at first, but it is not necessarily beneficial, so we should look at the problem in two; Putting facts and reasoning makes people shine. " I declare the debate officially open! First, please ask the representative of Party A to express his views. (Applause)

Party A:

Students, our view remains the same, that is, "opening books is beneficial." Everyone is familiar with the famous saying of Du Fu, a poet in the Tang Dynasty: "Reading breaks thousands of books, and writing is like a god." Books are the crystallization of human wisdom, the summary of human historical experience and the reflection of social life. Reading can deeply understand the meaning of life, understand the vicissitudes of the world, benefit the people all over the world, and enter the hall of wisdom. Since ancient times, people who want to become talents and scholars who want to help the world must study. Only by reading a lot of books can you become a man. How can Party B say "reading is useless"?

Party b a:

We reminded male debaters not to confuse our views. When we say "opening books may not be beneficial", we don't mean not reading, but adopting the correct reading method. You just said "open book is beneficial". We can see that there are good books, bad books and even "poisonous books". How can you read it indiscriminately? Besides, those so-called comic books, such as Wulongyuan, The Journey to the West and Snow from Winter to Sun, seem to have a special appetite for our primary school students. You think, my eyes are fixed, the content is unhealthy, and my eyesight is declining. What should I do? Not to mention those books with bad tendencies such as love killing, fortune telling, and malicious teasing of historical figures, which have a very bad influence on us children, it is really better not to open them.

Party A and Party B:

The ancients said, "Eating without meat is better than living without bamboo." Bamboo is also an elegant person. In other words, we can eat no meat for one day and study for one day. Books are the nourishment of human spirit, which can make us strong and noble. Pay attention to eye hygiene and rest for half an hour. At the same time, as long as we pay attention to reading books in regular bookstores, we won't see books with unhealthy thoughts.

Party B:

We still can't accept each other's views. There are two reasons: first, the current bookstores are affected by the market economy and the competition is fierce. In order to make money, some unscrupulous booksellers do whatever it takes to adulterate some unhealthy books and even sell pornographic books. Second, our pupils are young and have weak self-control. When they see such a book, they can't stand the temptation and even forget to eat and sleep. Once hooked, you will be possessed, have no mind in class, and your grades will plummet. Some even imitate the characters in the book, so they embarked on the road of crime. Doesn't this confirm our view that "opening books is not necessarily beneficial" or even harmful?

Party A and Party C:

I want the facts to speak for themselves. At all times and in all countries, which effective person has not opened his book thousands of times? It is because of reading that they became famous and made great achievements. Confucius read thousands of books and edited poetry books. Sima Qian read thousands of books and wrote historical records. Li Bai read thousands of books and wrote hundreds of poems about fighting wine; Lu Xun and Guo Moruo read thousands of books and became masters of modern literature in China ... Gorky put it well: "Books are the ladder of human progress." It has become an ironclad fact that reading more books increases knowledge and makes people smart. The British philosopher Bacon famously said, "History lessons make people wise, poetry makes them wise, mathematics makes them careful, natural history makes them profound, and ethics makes them solemn." Many of these meanings can be summed up in one sentence: opening books is beneficial. If we don't study, where can we get knowledge? What's more, there are countless famous sayings about the benefits of reading. Let's talk about it Can't the experience summed up by so many celebrities and great men fully explain that "opening books is beneficial"?

Party B and Party C:

We have to admire the ability of Party A's debater to change the debate. However, the male debater used many famous sayings, which did not hide our correct views, but proved our correct views. If sages like Confucius, Sima Qian, Li Bai, Lu Xun and Guo Moruo do not read good books with healthy thoughts and carry forward the fine traditions of the Chinese nation, but read bad books that poison people, will they become famous and get married? Liu Xiang, a thinker in the Han Dynasty, once said: "Books are still medicine, and good reading can cure fools." How accurate and vivid his words are! Since the book is a medicine blindly, it has two functions: first, it is a good medicine, exhorting life, curing ignorance, kindness and beauty, naturally curing diseases after taking it, and making people sober, noble and ambitious; One is poison, which confuses life, makes people more ignorant, turns ugliness into evil, makes people arrogant, has low virtue, has no ambition and even kills people. Right? A philosopher once said that a smart person is a person who can get the necessary nutrition. So we always believe that in the process of reading, we must learn to choose books. Resolutely don't read those harmful books, don't blindly believe famous sayings, and deceive yourself with what "opening books is beneficial"; What's more, you can't read everything with the so-called "curious" mentality. Such uncoiling is not only useless, but also harmful.

Moderator:

The debate between the two sides was very exciting, which fully demonstrated their views and benefited the audience present. The two sides expounded the significance, function, methods and approaches of reading from different angles. Personally, I think: both sides should put facts and reason, so as to understand "why study" and "how to study?" These two questions. Debate let us know that students should "read more books and read good books" since childhood, let the bright sunshine of healthy thoughts illuminate our beautiful childlike innocence, let colorful knowledge water our dried-up hearts, and read more good books on the premise of correctly choosing books suitable for children, so as to truly achieve the purpose of opening books. This is the end of the debate. Thank you again for your wonderful speeches and your active participation. See you in the next debate! (Applause)

A thematic debate on whether it is beneficial to open books.

Teacher Li comments:

From a certain height, this paper expounds the viewpoints of "opening books is beneficial" and "opening books is not necessarily beneficial" from different angles, and combined with the actual situation of extracurricular reading of primary school students, it shows its own position: not only to read more books, but also to read good books selectively. The correct viewpoint, clear facts, theory and practice make the argument incisive and refreshing. This paper fully shows the healthy and progressive character, the spirit of pursuing truth and the personality charm of being brave in exploring and enterprising, which makes us gasp in admiration.