Is Guan Yu doomed to fail in Maicheng?

In fact, after losing Jingzhou, Guan still chose to bear the humiliation and start all over again, but his personality was aloof and he couldn't stand this kind of failure, so he lost Maicheng. From this perspective, Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng is also a doomed ending.

In fact, as early as Liu Beijin Xichuan, he thought of this problem when he dispatched Jingzhou army reinforcements. Jingzhou garrison generals Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and Liu Bei left no one but Guan Yu. I hope Guan Yu can guard Jingzhou for him and protect the rear.

Guan Yu has been brave and invincible since he followed Liu Bei. Before Si Shuiguan, "warm wine cut Hua Xiong", Hulao Pass "fought against the three British soldiers", and Bai Mapo cut Yan Liang and crossed Wen Chou, riding thousands of miles alone. Even in Huarong Road, Cao Cao could almost kill him if he didn't beg.

It can be said that Guan Yu's fame is well known all over the world. When Cao Cao sent Yujin and Pound to Jingzhou to fight Guan Yu, Pound told people that I would go this time to defeat Guan Yu's heroism in China for forty years.

However, Yu Jin and Pound are no match for Guan Yu. Fan Cheng and Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, Yu Jin was captured and Pound was killed.

Guan Yu, on the other hand, is conceited because of his martial arts and fame. He never takes dignitaries seriously. Sun Quan wanted his son to marry Guan Yu's daughter, but Guan Yu flatly refused. He also insulted the messenger and said, "Can my tiger girl marry a son?"

It is precisely because of his personality that Zhuge Liang ran counter to the strategy of "uniting Sun Wu in the east and rejecting Cao Cao in the north" before he entered Shu. Therefore, Sun Quan took advantage of the opportunity of fighting Cao Cao to sneak up on Guan Yu's rear while Jingzhou was empty.

Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and refused to put down his face and bend his knees to surrender. This was only available when he was arrested in Maicheng. Sun Quan was afraid of the strength of the Shu army and finally ordered the killing of Guan Yu.