Fortune Telling Collection - Comprehensive fortune-telling - Can you only admit that you were unlucky and killed by a psychopath? The judge said stay away from them.

Can you only admit that you were unlucky and killed by a psychopath? The judge said stay away from them.

The news that the owner of Wuhan noodle restaurant was beheaded by diners continues to ferment, and the discussion around this murder case is also polarized: one party thinks that the deceased should be restrained so that it will not end in death; On the other hand, the noodle shop owner should not be deprived of his life no matter how bad his attitude is.

Such an argument will never have a final result, because those of us who are not the parties always stay out of it and feel that everything we say is extremely correct. However, the news of Red Star News made it more dramatic.

According to the media interview, the suspect Hu holds a disability certificate issued by the Disabled Persons' Federation in Xuanhan County, his hometown. The disability category is "spirit" and the disability level is "level 2". In other words, Hu is actually a mental patient. According to the provisions of Article 18 of the Criminal Law, a mental patient who causes harmful results when he is unable to identify or control his own behavior and is confirmed by court procedures shall not bear criminal responsibility.

When many people are condemning Hu's violent killings, this news may turn public opinion again. A "mental patient" went to the noodle restaurant to eat noodles. He had an argument with the store because of a dollar, and then he hacked the store to death with a kitchen knife in a rage. After the murder, Hu did not escape, but waited for the police to catch him.

Although the case is still under investigation, Hu's evidence of "mental disability" will inevitably affect the future direction of the case. If it is finally determined that Hu was killed by mental illness, he probably does not need to bear criminal responsibility. He only needs strict supervision and medical treatment from his family or guardians, and the government will force medical treatment when necessary.

But according to Hu's family and Hu's behavior, he should be an intermittent mental patient. According to the criminal law, an intermittent mental patient who commits a crime when he is mentally normal should bear criminal responsibility. If a mental patient who has not completely lost the ability to recognize or control his own writing commits a crime, he shall bear criminal responsibility, but he may be given a lighter or mitigated punishment.

No matter what the final result of this case is, I believe it will not satisfy everyone. The crime of mental patients has always been a controversial topic, not only in China, but also in the United States.

The assassination of former US President Ronald Reagan should be regarded as the most famous "psychotic homicide" in American history. A man named John? Sinclair's men, armed with guns, inexplicably fired several shots at the president of the United States and almost killed Reagan. Brady, the press secretary standing next to Reagan, was shot in the head and eventually disabled for life.

The motive for the assassination, and later the investigation found that Sinclair was just trying to attract movie star Judy? Foster's attention. At the time of the lawsuit, Sinclair's father hired a very strong team of lawyers, who exhausted everything and defined Sinclair as a mental disorder and a sudden mental illness during the crime. In this way, Sinclair was acquitted by the court

The result of this trial left everyone speechless at that time. But Sinclair's later ending comforted some people. Because Sinclair was proved to be "possibly mentally ill" and "extremely dangerous and violent", according to the law, he must receive treatment. So Sinclair was sent to the most horrible Elizabeth mental hospital in the United States for treatment, and he was not allowed to leave, and even his parents could not see him.

Up to now, more than 30 years have passed and Sinclair himself has changed from a young man to a 60-year-old man. He is still in Elizabeth mental hospital. Besides, it is said that he is really crazy this time.

Even so, for those who have been deprived of their lives or have been hurt, the loss can never be made up. However, the debate about the crime of mental patients has been inconclusive.

There is a question in Zhihu, "Is it bad luck to be killed by a mental patient?" Most of the answers are yes.

A netizen named "Ai Fa" claimed to be a judge, and his answer was: Please stay away from mental illness. They really don't have to be responsible for killing people. This answer has won more than 7,000 praises.

According to the results of some criminal cases of mental patients in China, it seems to be in line with this conclusion.

Less than ten days ago, a murder case of a mental patient occurred in a furniture factory in Majuqiao Town, Beijing. Finally, the suspect was identified as paranoid mental disorder. When committing an illegal act, he was dominated by psychopathic factors and lost the ability to identify and control, so he was assessed as having no criminal responsibility.

A netizen said that some small county criminal police handle 3-5 cases of patients wounding or killing each year. After the general accident, the suspect is arrested the next day, and after identification, if he has no criminal responsibility at the time of committing the crime, he will be sent to a rehabilitation hospital, then reported to the procuratorate and the court for compulsory treatment, and then sent to a prescribed hospital. Basically, they will be here all their lives.

Therefore, he called for: when encountering mental patients with violent tendencies, we must avoid them in time! When you encounter a mental patient with a violent tendency, you must avoid it in time! When you encounter a mental patient with a violent tendency, you must avoid it in time! Say the important things three times.