Is the "Shen Si" in the eight characters broken or the "Hua Shui" in Liuhe, which is correct?

Don't melt water under any circumstances, and don't be misled by the incorrect theory of ancient books.

It doesn't matter whether it is broken or not. Which one to restrain depends on their position and strength in the eight characters.

Although these are some problems in numerology, they are comprehensive and not as simple as you think. So we should start with the basics, and then find some acquaintances to infer and verify. Practice is the most important thing. No matter how many empty theories there are, the theory verified by practice is correct.