New fortune telling _ new fortune telling bar

Why is psychoanalysis abandoned by modern psychology?

I'm uncle Zuo, a psychology teacher, and I'll answer your question.

I am a worker who is engaged in psychology and mental health education consultation, and I am doing psychological health education consultation for students in a university.

First, you are a false proposition, and there is no such thing as psychoanalysis being abandoned by modern psychology.

The psychological counseling theory and technology I applied in psychological counseling practice are oriented by psychoanalysis. I feel deeply about the contribution of psychoanalysis to modern psychology. My understanding is that psychoanalysis has not been abandoned by modern psychology, but psychoanalysis has been paid more and more attention by modern psychology. Psychoanalytic therapy is still one of the most important therapies in modern psychotherapy, and it is also called the five major therapies of psychotherapy with behaviorism therapy, humanistic psychotherapy, cognitive behavioral therapy and family therapy. This alone shows that modern psychology has not abandoned psychoanalysis.

Secondly, the development of psychoanalysis since its birth, from the first generation of classical psychoanalysis to the second generation of new psychoanalysis to the third generation of new psychoanalysis, also shows that psychoanalysis itself is adapting to the development of modern psychology. For example, in order to adapt to the development of modern psychology, psychoanalysis has developed its own schools, such as neuropsychology, object relationship theory and self-psychology, which not only revolutionized classical psychoanalysis, but also influenced children's psychology, developmental psychology, clinical psychology and personality psychology in modern psychology. For example, Eriksson's theory of eight stages of personality development contributes to the theory of developmental psychology, and Adler's theory of inferiority contributes to the theory of personality psychology.

Third, I can only say that people who hold this argument, first, people without psychological background do not understand the development and present situation of psychology; The second is the prejudice of scientific psychology against psychoanalysis, because psychology has been divided into two camps since its birth, one is scientific psychology represented by Feng Te, and the other is empirical psychology represented by Freud. The two camps never stopped attacking each other.

I hope my answer is helpful to you. If you have different opinions, please leave a message in the comments section, and we can continue our discussion and share our views.

Thanks again for the invitation!

Hehe, scientific psychology? Can measuring cups, vernier calipers, scales and thermometers measure depression? Anxiety? Love and hate?

A patient with depression, doing CT, testing blood, urine and blood pressure, is the result normal, can it be used as evidence to prescribe a prescription for treating depression?

Science should stay away from psychology!

Modern psychology does not give up psychoanalysis, but tends to return to psychoanalysis, because most of the newly invented therapies of other schools are unsatisfactory, which is basically a drop in the bucket compared with psychoanalysis. Psychoanalytic therapy has had a low tide since it was founded, but it has survived so far not because of luck, but because the theory objectively reflects the inherent essential characteristics of human psychology. In essence, the theories of other schools are based on psychoanalysis. Although some of their representatives openly oppose psychoanalysis, it is a pity that they have to use psychoanalytic theory to oppose psychoanalysis. In essence, the value of these school theories is only a part of psychoanalytic buildings or ancillary facilities, far from being an independent psychoanalysis. In short, there is actually only one kind of psychology, that is, psychoanalysis. Other therapies are just a change of clothes, and their essence is still not divorced from the framework constructed by psychoanalysis.

Why is psychoanalysis abandoned by modern psychology? Real science must have vitality, and when it encounters stubborn resistance, it will also show the brilliance of life at the heaviest time. Before Copernicus put forward Heliocentrism, people all over the world thought that the earth was the center, and the church burned Bruno who insisted on the truth alive, but truth is truth, which cannot be stopped by a government or a church. Britain sent a generator to the imperial palace of the Qing Dynasty to light it up at night, but Empress Dowager Cixi refused to use it, but Cixi could not stop the electric light from entering every household in China.

Newton's classical mechanics has been shining for more than 300 years and has made great contributions to the progress of human society. Because classical mechanics is scientific and can't stand scrutiny.

The theoretical basis of schizophrenia is problematic. The formation of neurosis is attributed to sex, which leads to inefficiency or even ineffectiveness of counseling. Nowadays, the so-called dynamic counselors focus on vocabulary research such as empathy, projection and regression. And farther and farther away from the core of mental illness. Strangely, these people can do effective counseling.

It is normal to be abandoned without scientific basis and imagination.

Treating depression as a mental illness is ineffective, and you will naturally find reasons to quit. Think about what chronic diseases have been cured by western medicine? Taking medicine every day means that science has been deeply rooted in people's hearts. Don't be silly, just find a folk doctor to treat you.

There are counselors and priests in the west.

China has fortune tellers, Chinese medicine practitioners and family ties.

How can a theory that cannot be verified and demonstrated be accepted by modern science? If it cannot be falsified, it will not be accepted by science.

By the way, modern psychology is a part of science. Since Feng Te established the first psychology laboratory, psychology has finally become a part of science and has been accepted by science. Both social science and natural science need to meet the basic requirements of science, while psychoanalysis cannot be falsified and concrete, so it has been eliminated by science and not accepted by modern psychology.