A Dream of Red Mansions TV series 1987 or 20 10 is better? Why?

To be fair, the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions is much more advanced in film and television technology than the 87 version. There are even some improvements in thinking: for example, the 87 th edition did not shoot a fantasy, because? Promote feudal superstition? Today, it seems both regrettable and ridiculous, which is an absolute regret.

I think if there is no comparison between version 87 and version 10, it will definitely be reviled, but it is better than the present situation. In other words, the 10 version was criticized, largely because of the gap with the 87 version.

Where is the gap? Whether it's copper coins, haunted music, or fox-like coquettish laughter, different people have different views, including rejection and preference. But in role-playing, the gap between 10 version is obvious to all, and no one can deny it.

It's not which actor looks good and which actor acts like it, but the whole. The 87 version of Chen is simply the reincarnation of Lin Daiyu, and no one can deny it. In fact, Chen's ancient makeup is not particularly beautiful, and some stills are not even comparable to her life photos. Put it with Zhang Li to make people have more? Is Daiyu not as beautiful as Baochai? The feeling. But Chen's temperament, among all the actresses I have seen so far, is nothing more like Lin Daiyu.

Some of Chen's later films, such as Cousin Mei in Family Spring and Autumn, are also images of women from poor families. But no matter how good the performance is, at first glance, it will still make people feel that this role is played by Sister Lin. ?

Like this? Stereotype? It is unfortunate for an actor. But for the drama, it is a blessing. What happened to Chen also happened to many other actors. Basically, except Deng Jie, the actor of Wang Xifeng, no other actors have surpassed the works of A Dream of Red Mansions.

It depends on the life of a scene. In addition to the director's unique vision of role selection, it depends on the efforts of the actors. It is said that the actors concentrated on studying for a whole year before shooting (some people say it was three years! Some people say it's a few months. However, during the three-year filming process, the actors never stopped learning and had a deep understanding of ancient culture, etiquette, living habits and costumes. It really shot, didn't it? Acting? , but for self? Show? Yes

We can't deny that the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions has made great efforts, but at least, it can't be compared with the 87 version in terms of the actors' grasp of classical culture. Although the words are? Life is like a play, all by acting? But if there is really only acting left, can this movie become a classic?

By the way, although version 87 is classic, it is not without defects, and even there are obvious loopholes in detail handling. For example, Xue Pan killed Pan Feng and sent a book to Beijing. Mrs. Wang read the letter and gave it to Wang Xifeng. However, in the works, Mrs. Wang's culture is very low, and whether she can read or not is not described. The first half of Wang Xifeng is absolutely illiterate. For example, she joked with Tanchun: You know how to read, but you don't learn fortune telling? ? I didn't write it until the seventy-fourth volume of the Grand View Garden? As the director in charge, Xifeng often reads posts and accounts and knows a lot of words. .