Wang Lang Wealth _ Wang Lang Truth

Is The Romance of the Three Kingdoms a fiction?

Is The Romance of the Three Kingdoms a fiction? On the basis of truth, construct a fictional plot, with eight false points and two true points.

The main line of history and characters are basically true.

The historical trend is true, but the shaping of historical figures has undergone artistic treatment, including many fictional stories.

It can't be said that they are all fictional. At least the endings of many battles and the tactics used in some battles are true, but the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is still true.

But it is a novel, and it can't escape the novel writing method of three points being true and seven points being false.

The basic facts are all true.

But both characterization and historical events are processed.

With a strong subjective color.

Feudal orthodoxy and support for Liu's anti-Cao are very strong.

Is Luo Guanzhong's Romance of the Three Kingdoms a fiction? What I know is that in Yanjin War, Guan Yu beheaded Wen Chou, and Wen Chou led an army to attack Cao with Liu Bei. As a result, he was trapped by Cao Cao and died in the disorderly army. Guan Yu's weapon is not a dragon crescent moon blade, but is compiled by later generations to set off martial arts; Zhao Zilong spent seven holidays only to protect Liu Bei's family and save Adou; Cao Cao defeated Huarong Jia Dao; Zhuge Liang's empty city plan is false; The story of diusim is not exactly recorded in history. The story of diusim is just something that dignitaries wear on their hats; Zhang Yide angered Du You and was Liu Bei; Zhang Banpo and Zhang Fei broke the holiday of Dangyang Bridge, only tearing it down; Zhou Yu was not sad because of Zhuge, but she was generous and gentle. Grass boats borrow arrows and make fakes; Taoyuan sworn history books said nothing, but recorded three human feelings as brothers; Wei Yan didn't object, just fighting for power with Yang Yi, which would be incompatible rather than anti-China; Zhou Cang, there is no record of helping Guan Yu with a knife in history; What Guan Yu didn't do was escort his sister-in-law to Beige, but he didn't kill any generals. Others are not fools. Do you know you can't get through the gate? You can't kill Guan Yu; Guo Jia collected Liaodong holiday, and Cao Cao himself later waited; Zhuge's military talent is not as good as his own political talent. In romance, he fights all day and is in charge of internal affairs. It was Liu Bei's fault that Bowangpo burned Cao Jun. It's hard to say whether his brother went there at that time. According to the records of Fei Zong, he went, but there was no war with Lu Bu. And many, many more.

The fictional plot of Zhang Fei's words in Romance of the Three Kingdoms: Zhang Fei's words are beneficial to virtue, but not to virtue.

Taoyuan Jieyi: Although Liu and Liu are not sworn, they are brothers. Guan Yu is even older than Liu Bei.

Famous vessels: double-edged sword, dragon crescent moon blade, Zhang Ba snake spear, Tian Fang painted halberd, Lu Qingjian and other famous vessels are all fictitious.

Zhang Fei whipped Du You: It was Liu Beigan. Because Du You refused to see Liu Bei, Liu Bei was furious and beat Du You with a stick.

Cao Cao offered the Seven Stars Knife: Fiction. In Romance, Cao Cao tried to assassinate Dong Zhuo with a knife. In fact, Cao Cao thought that Dong Zhuo would eventually be defeated and fled to his hometown overnight.

Sun Jian's death: When he was chasing the enemy, he only took a few followers, but he was ambushed by Huang Zu and died in Xianshan.

Tao Qian: Tao Qian's personality is inconsistent with historical facts.

It was also Liu Beigan who executed Che Zhou by Guan Yu and Xuzhou.

There are three things about Tu Shan: Although "Tu Shan talked about three things", Guan Yu surrendered because of Liu Bei's family background.

Imperial edict with blood in clothes: Yes, but Marten is a bandit warlord, and attacking LiGuo is only a personal vendetta.

Red hare: Red hare disappeared after Lu Bu's defeat. Did not become Guan Yu's mount.

Guan Yu killed Wen Chou: Wen Chou died in Cao Jun's rebellion, probably by soldiers of Guan Yu, Zhang Liao or Huang Xu.

Sun Ce's death: He was assassinated by an assassin, who was a domestic slave and guest of Xu Gong, the former prefect of Wu County, and was not scared to death by Yu Ji.

Go through five hurdles and kill six generals: a fictional story. After Guan Yu left Cao Cao, he didn't go through five customs, and Kong Xiu, Meng Tan, Han Fu, Bian Xi, Wang Zhi and Chyi Chin were not recorded in the history books. However, it cannot be denied that there is no obstacle in the middle.

Guo Jia left a plan for Liaodong: a fictional plot. Guo Jia died suddenly at the age of 38, leaving no plans. This plan is Cao Cao's own plan.

Guan Yu beheaded Cai Yang in the ancient city: Liu Beigan did it, not in the ancient city.

Xu Shu's wisdom: Xu Shu is not recorded much in the official history.

Xu Shu entered Cao Cao's camp: Cao Cao marched south, Xu Shu fled with Liu Beinan, Xu Mu was captured in the mutiny, Xu Shu bid farewell to Liu Bei and entered Cao Cao's camp, and later became an important minister of Wei State.

Visiting the thatched cottage was in the summer of 2008, not in the winter of 2007. Liu Bei met Zhuge Liang every time.

Zhuge Liang set fire to Bowangpo: It was Liu Beigan again, before Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain.

Zhuge Liang set fire to a new field: it is not recorded in history and was invented for Luo Guanzhong.

Zhao Yun of Changbanpo went in and out seven times: In history, Zhao Yun only escorted Liu Bei's family to retreat, and there is no record of this. Zhaoyun was not famous at that time.

Mrs. Mi jumped into the well: It is not recorded in the official history.

Liu Cong was killed: after being given to Jingzhou, he was appointed as the secretariat of Qingzhou by Cao Cao, and was made a marquis, but he was not killed. Later, in recognition of his achievements, Cao Cao suggested becoming a doctor.

Wu Guotai: A fictional character.

Debate among Confucians: It is only recorded that Zhuge Liang and Sun Quan met, and the warring factions and pacifists in Soochow are increasingly contending. Zhuge Liang is just a thrifty messenger.

After Zhou recounted Jiang Gan, Jiang Gan and Battle of Red Cliffs, lobbying Zhou Yu failed.

Taishi Ci died in 2007 and did not attend Battle of Red Cliffs.

Zhuge Liang challenged Zhou Yu: It should be Zhou who challenged Sun Quan.

Grass boat borrows arrow: there is no such thing. A similar incident happened in Sun Quan's Battle of ruxu Dock.

Bitter plan: Huang Gai did have a fake surrender, but there should be no bitter plan.

Kan Ze: Kan Ze is an important minister of Wu Dong and deeply respected by Sun Quan. He has never taken part in military action.

Pang Tong offered a series of tricks: It was Cao Cao's decision to go to the forest, and Pang Tong had never been to Battle of Red Cliffs.

Kong Ming asked Dongfeng: It's pure fiction. There is a southeast wind in Jiangdong from winter to Sunday.

Battle of Red Cliffs: Both Shu Wei and Shu Shu recorded that Cao Cao was defeated in the war with Liu Bei. Sun Quanjun did take part in the battle, but it was difficult to get all the credit.

Zhou Yu: Battle of Red Cliffs, a famous Soochow player, did not personally conduct the front line. Two years later, he died on the way to West Shu, and he never saw Zhuge Liang again.

Huarong said, Liu Bei led the troops to chase Cao Cao, but he was defeated, but he was late and Cao Ran took him away.

South county dispute: it didn't happen. After Zhou Yu's death, Sun Quan lent Jiangling to Liu Bei. Borrowing Jiangling (Jingzhou was divided by Cao, Sun and Liu at that time, and Sun Quan had no right to "borrow Jingzhou") was just Lu Su's idea, in order to give Cao Cao a powerful enemy.

Guan Yu fought against Huang Zhong: Liu Bei was in the south of Jingnan, and the governors of the four counties suffered from the wind, so Huang Zhong surrendered with Han Xuan, the prefect of Changsha.

Sun Liu's marriage: the marriage between Mrs. Sun and Liu Bei is only a political marriage, but there is indeed a record in the biography of the fierce woman that she threw herself into the river. Moreover, it was not Zhou Yu's idea, but Sun Quan volunteered.

Losing his wife and losing his soldiers: Sun Quan did not adopt Zhou Yu's honey trap.

Zhou Yu is narrow-minded: History records Zhou Yu's broad-minded, generous and friendly style. And I haven't even met Zhuge. How can I be jealous?

Sanyu: Zhou Yu died before going to Xishu. Zhou Yu died of illness in Baqiu on the way to cutting Shu. Not by Zhuge Liang's intelligence.

Wolong funeral in Sanjiangkou: Zhou Yu was hanged by Pang Tong, not Zhuge Liang.

Zhou Yu and Kong Ming: During the two years from the end of Battle of Red Cliffs to Zhou Yu's death, Zhuge Liang was in Lingling area.

Ma Chao transferred troops: Contrary to historical facts, Ma Chao transferred troops first, which led to Ma Teng's death.

Zhang Song presented a map: you should ask Liu Bei about the salary of the soldiers and horses in Shu, Zhang Song, so Zhang Song drew a map for Liu Bei.

Luo Fengpo: Pang Tong was killed by an arrow when he attacked Luocheng.

Ma Chao hit Zhang Fei: Ma Chao wrote to Liu Bei privately, demanding surrender. There is no plot in the novel in which Zhang Fei and Ma Chao fought for more than 200 rounds and were later surrendered by Zhuge Liang.

Hanzhong: Liu Bei is the commander-in-chief of Hanzhong, and Fa Zheng is the staff officer.

Planning to seize the sky and swing the mountains: pure fiction.

Dingjun Mountain: Xia was attacked by Liu Beijun at night and died. Although Huang Zhong didn't kill him, Huang Zhong made great contributions in this battle.

Cao Cao killed Yang Xiu: Yang Xiu was not killed on the eve of Cao Cao's withdrawal. In fact, he was killed after Cao Cao withdrew. In the official history, there is no case that Cao Cao killed Yang Xiu and fought with the Shu army, and Wei Yan knocked out his front teeth.

Five Tiger Generals: Liu Bei didn't have the title of "Five Tiger Generals", but only four generals, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao and Huang Zhong. The reason why the Five Tigers joined the army was that the biographies of Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Huang Zhong and Zhao Yun were put in the same chapter in the Three Kingdoms. Later generations called the Five Tigers General Army.

Zhou Cang and Hu Ban: Fictional characters, not going down in history. Hu Ban may refer to Wu Ban, the general of Shu Han.

Guan Yu's Single Knife Meeting: In fact, Lu Su invited Guan Yu to discuss Jingzhou before the war, but the two sides failed to reach an agreement.

Curettage: At this time, Hua Tuo was killed in Battle of Red Cliffs, and was operated by a general doctor.

The seventh army was flooded: it was autumn, with heavy rain and the Hanshui River soaring. Guan Yu took advantage of the right time and place, led the water army to defeat the famous army, captured Pound alive, and led the army to attack urgently.

Guan Yu Maicheng refused to surrender: there is no record, but he refused to surrender after being captured.

Yuquan Sage and Monroe: Yuquan Sage was adapted from the story of building a temple in yuquan temple in Tang Dynasty, and Monroe died.

Seventy-two suspected graves: Cao Cao was buried in Gaoling.

Guan Ping: Guan Yu's eldest son, not his adopted son, joined the army, and his name only appeared twice in the History of the Three Kingdoms.

Guan Xing: The weak crown (nearly 20 years old) is highly valued by Zhuge Liang because of his ability to do things and supervise the army. The battle of Yiling died a few years later.

Zhang Bao: Although he died young, he left a son, Zhang Zun.

Mi Fang: There was no case of being executed by Ling Chi when he fled to Shuying. After the battle of Yiling, he did go to Qichun area of Wei with He Qi.

Kan Ze recommended Lu Xun: Lu Xun was Monroe's deputy in Jingzhou. After Monroe's death, it was naturally Lu Xun who took over the defense of Wudong West Line.

The battle of Yiling: more than 100,000 in Wu Jun and 80,000 in Shu. It's not that there are many people, but that Wu Jun's morale is really low.

Pan Zhang's Death: Pan Zhang made a meritorious military service for Sun Quan in the battle of Yiling, hacked Feng and others, and died in 234.

Bai Di entrusted orphans: Liu Bei entrusted orphans to Zhuge Liang and Li Yan when he died, but he still said to Zhuge Liang, "You are only ten times better than Cao Pi, and you will be able to settle down in the world and eventually achieve great things. If the heir can supplement it, supplement it; If you are incompetent, you can take it yourself. "

Eight-array diagram: Eight-array diagram is the art of war array made by Zhuge Liang, not a strange stone array or maze.

Seven captures of Meng Huo: There is no record of seven captures of Meng Huo in The History of the Three Kingdoms. However, there is a saying of "seven captures and seven verticals" in Han Shu Jin Shu Hua Yang Guo Zhi Chun Qiu, but the specific process is not recorded. E Huan, Zhu Rong, Meng You and Muluwang were all created by novels.

Six visits to Qishan: Zhuge Liang attacked Wei five times, only the first and fourth visits to Qishan. Five of them were defeated by the street pavilion for the first time, and fought with Dongwu for the second time, but the siege failed. However, in his retreat, he killed the general Xinmeile Co., Ltd. (basically the same as the romance), successfully captured Wudu and Yin Ping counties for the third time, and defeated Guo Huai. The fourth time he was defeated by Sima Yi, and the fifth time Sima Yi dared not fight.

Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang: During Zhuge Liang's first three northern expeditions, Wei Jun was not commanded by Sima Yi, but by Cao Zhen.

Lost Street Pavilion: The commander in chief of Wei Jun is Zhang Jaw, not Sima Yi.

Empty plan: After the defeat of Jieting, Wei Jun did not pursue the Shu army. Zhuge Liang just moved the people and food in the west county. At that time, Wei Jun was not Sima Yi. The real empty plan was hired by Wei and used by Zhao Yun, a general of Shu.

Angry Cao Zhen: Cao Zhen died of illness in Luoyang.

Zhuge Liang cursed Wang Lang's death: Wang Lang died in 228 and did not go out with the army.

Above: Zhuge Liang defeated Wei Jun in Lucheng, and Sima Yi only saved the camp with his body. The Three Kingdoms did not mention what tactics were used to break Wei Jun, and there was no big difference between Shaanxi rural legends and romance; Above the valley, when it comes to Hulu Valley, it is suspected to be the nickname of Lucheng.

Zhuge Liang's death scared away the living Zhong Da: it did happen, and it was not Zhuge Liang's legacy. It is recorded in Hanshu, Jin Shu, Chunqiu that after Zhuge Liang's death, the Shu army retreated quietly, and Sima Yi noticed it and led the army to catch up. When the two armies approached, Jiang Wei, the general of Shu, and Yang Yi, the chief historian, ordered the Shu army to feint, but Sima Yi dared not approach and had to retreat, and the Shu army went into the valley to send out obituaries. At that time, the joke "Zhuge died, Zhong Dasheng" spread all over the country.

Wei Yan rebelled and was killed by Ma Dai: Wei Yan was at odds with Yang Yi, Zhuge Liang disobeyed orders after his death and was killed after the failure of the struggle. Before Zhuge Liang's death, Wei Yan was reused, and there was no such thing as "being forced to the bone".

Nine trips to the Central Plains: In fact, Jiang Wei made as many as eleven northern expeditions, of which the victory and defeat were equally divided. Most of the eight northern expeditions were fictitious.

Geographical relocation: move Taibai Mountain to the side of Qishan, move Chencang to the south of Jieting, even move Qishan to the diagonal valley north of Baoxie Road, or move it to the vicinity of Wuzhangyuan.

What are the fictional records about Changbanpo in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms? The first master was chased by Tsao Kung in Changban, Dangyang, abandoned his wife and went south, holding his weak son, the last master, to protect Mrs. Gan, the last mistress. Move to the general's yamen. When my ancestors went to Shu, why did they stay in Jingzhou? The cloud does not spread: at the beginning, the first master was defeated. Some people say that the cloud has gone north, and the first master gestured with his hand: "Zilong will not abandon me." In a moment, dark clouds will come. Not as vivid as described in romance novels.

Is Guan Ju God in Romance of the Three Kingdoms fictional? That's not true.

Guan Ju (209-256), a warlock of Wei State in the Three Kingdoms period, was born in the plain (now Shandong Plain). When I was eight or nine years old, I liked watching the stars. As an adult, he is proficient in Zhouyi, good at divination, face reading and learning bird language. According to legend, every word is superb He is generous, ugly and has no dignity, and often returns good for evil. In the early Yuan Dynasty, he was a junior official.

Guan Ju was revered as the ancestor of divination by later generations, and his representative works include 2 volumes of Zhouyi Tongling Tactics, 1 volume of Zhouyi Tongling Tactics 1, 1 volume of Duankuangjing 1 and 1 volume of Zhan Ji 1. The Biography of the Three Kingdoms and Ji Fang compares Guanluo's medical skills to "Hua Tuo's medical diagnosis, Du Kui's vocal music, Zhu Jianping's physiognomy, and Zhou Xuanzhi's dream", and thinks that it is "sincere, mysterious and ingenious, very unique."

Good at divination.

Is Guan Yu proficient in Zhouyi when he grows up? Astronomy, geography, divination and geomantic omen are all subtle, but their faces are rough, and they are not mighty. They are good at drinking and joking, no matter who they are. So the locals like him very much, but they don't respect him. Guan Lu's father is an official in Cao Li. The three brothers, Guo En, a local resident, had to get rid of the illness and let Guan Lu calculate the fortune.

Guan Lu said, "The divination says that your family has a grave, and one of the women is a dead fool, not your aunt, but her aunt. Once upon a time, life was hard, and someone wanted to get her a few liters of rice and push her into the well. She struggled for a while after entering the water. The man in the well pushed down another big stone and killed your aunt. The lonely soul was wronged and complained to the sky. "

Hearing these words, Guo En cried and confessed. Guangping Liu's wife is very ill and has bought a coffin for the funeral. It was the first month, so please count it. Guan Lu said after the calculation: "Her fate didn't end until noon in August." Liu didn't believe it, but his wife's condition gradually improved. Died of illness in autumn. Sure enough, as Guan Lu said.

Guan Ju went to see JI Wang, the magistrate of Anping. JI Wang told him to go to divination, and Guan Ju said, "A lowly woman will give birth to a boy, leave as soon as she lands, and die as soon as she walks into the pot. There will be a big snake on the bed with a pen in its mouth. The whole family can visit and leave soon. Another bird flew into the house and fought with the swallow. The swallow died and the bird flew away. These are three strange things. "

JI Wang? Be frightened and seek good or bad luck. Guan Ju said, "It's just that your family lives far away and something happened. The little boy was born to walk, not himself, but an unscrupulous demon. The serpent has a pen in his mouth, just an old book assistant. Birds and swallows fight, and the old clock falls. Today's divination is just a phenomenon, not murder. I know it's not a symbol of disaster, so don't worry. " The result is good.

At that time, the wives of Xindu county magistrate's family were inexplicably afraid and fell ill one after another, so let Guan Lu do the math. Guan Ju said, "There are two dead people in the west of Rubei Mansion, one with a spear and the other with a bow and arrow, with their heads inside the wall and their feet outside. The spear holder has a headache in the harem and can't lift it. People shoot the chest and abdomen with bows and arrows, and the harem has a stomachache and heartache, so they can't eat. They wander around during the day and make trouble at night, which scares the women. " So the county magistrate sent someone to dig out the bones, and all the wives at home recovered.

Qinghe wangjing? Leave the government and go home. Guan Lu went to see him. Wang Jing said: "A strange thing happened recently, which was very unpleasant. Please calculate it. " Guan Yu said, "Gua Gua is not a monster. In front of your house, at night, there is a ribbon that flies into your arms like a swallow. It can make a deep sound. If you feel uneasy, unbutton your clothes as if the corner of your eye is still there, just call your wife to see. " Jing Wong cried and said, "That's what you said." Guan Ju said: "Auspicious, this is a sign of promotion, and it will appear soon." Soon, Wang Jing moved to Jiangxia House.

Are most of the stories in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms fictional? Seven points are empty, three points are real. Basically, the classic stories of celebrities are fictional, and only the main lines and major events are true.

The full name of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is Popular Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Just look at the name.

It is a novel popularized on the basis of the Three Kingdoms in order to meet the needs of people at that time.

Since it is a novel, there must be something fictional.

For example, Zhuge Liang's sacrifice to the east wind, the three vows of Taoyuan, riding the savior alone, and going through five customs and beheading six generals are all fictitious.

They also mythologized Zhao Yun, Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang, and vilified Zhang Fei, Zhou Yu and Cao Cao.

Zhuge Liang's talent is mainly manifested in internal affairs and diplomacy, but his military talent is not so strong.

And Zhao Yun and Guan Yu are completely myths, almost to the point of god.

According to the romance, Zhao Yun rode alone as a savior, beheaded more than 50 Cao Cao generals and killed hundreds of soldiers. How is that possible?

There is a saying that Zhang Fei is a handsome boy, not that kind of careless and rude image.

This is not groundless. The image of Zhang Fei on the stone tablet of General Five Tigers unearthed is not that kind of reckless man.

Moreover, The Romance of the Three Kingdoms has many mistakes. These are not caused by Lao Luo YY, but by Lao Luo's own negligence.

For example, write the name of Sun Shi (today's Sun Shangxiang) as Sun Ren.

The name Sun Ren is actually an alias of Sun Lang.

Lao Luo wrote all the names of the characters wrong, which shows how low the historical accuracy of The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is.

In a word, Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a novel adapted from YY to meet the needs of people at that time.

It's not a history book. It can't be so accurate.

In old China, people's education level was very low. After watching the romance several times, they thought that history was like this.

Actually, it is not. Personally, I think romance is just a pastime after dinner, and it also leads us to read the history of the Three Kingdoms.

The bridge between fiction and fiction is false, so we don't need to care too much.

Pure hand tour

How much of The Romance of The Three Kingdoms is fiction? About thirty percent! There are many historical events, but the protagonist has changed. For example, Liu Bei burned Bo Wangpo, but Zhuge Liang was written in the romance. In addition, the author also supports Liu's anti-Cao thought, which is mixed with personal feelings.

Seven points are real and three points are imaginary. I hope to adopt them. Thank you.