Why was Li Meijin scolded?

Why did Li Meijin become a hot expert in criminal psychology? Because she, as an influential public figure, made wild remarks about the case without any evidence, which made the public biased, especially provided Liu Xin and Liu Xinzhong fans with the idea of spreading rumors about Jiangge's case and discredited Jiangge's innocence. Liu Xin fans and related media made such remarks on various platforms and submitted their "evidence" to the second trial. At the end of 2022, the court of second instance upheld the original judgment after careful trial, gave Jiang a positive evaluation, and overturned the statement that Jiang Ge was "gay" and "the goal of Chen Shifeng" was Jiang Ge.

The following is transferred from Zhihu to the Lord. He spoke in more detail.

Love rat: How to recognize love rat at a glance? The third round table was broadcast on February 2, 2008+2065438, which caused widespread controversy.

Li Meijin's view has always been regarded as the "core evidence" of whitewashing Liu Xin by Liu Xin supporters (called "appealing to authority" in public opinion control): Professor Li Meijin said that Chen Shifeng wanted to kill Jiangge. Do you know this case better than Professor Li Meijin?

At the same time, Liu Xin team is hyping the topic of "Jiangge homosexuality". Li Meijin's point of view: "Liu Xin and Jiangge call each other' uncle' and' girl', which may be misunderstood by Chen Shifeng, and may be Chen Shifeng's motive for killing" has become another "core argument" of the Liu Xin team: Li Meijin said that homosexuality is related to the motive for killing! Professor Li Meijin is an expert. She knows you better than you do.

Li Meijin was attacked and abused after the opinions of the Round Table School formed public opinion. Professor Li Meijin didn't correct the wrong basic facts, but because of his rebellious psychology, he moved to the Liu Xin supporters camp, interacted with the supporters in Weibo and Liu Xinzhong, and made further "professional analysis" according to more wrong details provided by Liu Xin supporters.

Chen Lan 2 1 August Weibo

It is a fact that Professor Li Meijin stands in Liu Xin or Liu Xin.

Let's take a look at Professor Li Meijin's views on the Round Table School:

1. Judging from Chen Shifeng's criminal characteristics, his intention to kill Jiang Ge is also quite obvious. His first knife was very fatal, because under normal circumstances, if he resisted, it should be his hand. His first knife went straight to his throat, and his trachea and throat were cut in half. Judging from Chen Shifeng's knife method, Chen Shifeng is plotting to kill Jiangge.

Part of it shows that Li Meijin knows nothing about this case. First, the professor didn't know that Jiang Singh had five defensive injuries; Second, Professor Li Meijin didn't know that there were 14 lacerations on Jiangge's coat and shirt. Thirdly, because he didn't know the existence of defensive wounds and the tear on his clothes, Li Meijin believed Chen Shifeng's defense: My first knife was self-defense, and the result was fatal, so Jiangge lost consciousness and fell to the ground. After Jiangge fell to the ground, Jiangge died before I repaired the knife 10- 1 1, so I was an attempted murderer.

Li Meijin thought that Chen Shifeng's first cut was fatal (No.6 wound), so he cut the trachea, and based on this, it was ridiculous to analyze the motive of killing by analyzing the "knife method".

2. Liu Xin and Jiangge call each other "uncle" and "girl", which are easily misunderstood and may stimulate Chen Shifeng. This may be Chen Shifeng's motive for killing.

"Uncle" and "maiden" are not their private names. While studying in a language school in Tokyo, Liu Xin moved to Jiangge Dormitory halfway. There are four people in the dormitory, so they are called "uncle" and "girl". This is what four people in the dormitory call each other. In the girls' dormitory, this name is normal.

If Chen Shifeng will be stimulated to kill by a name, how will Chen Shifeng react to Liu Xin's new boyfriend?

The real motive of Chen Shifeng's murder, or who he wants to kill, has long been decided by the court.

The verdict of Jiangge's murder case

Because Jiangge was an obstacle to Chen Shifeng's murder, he deliberately killed Jiangge, and of course he had a strong sense of murder.

The object of Chen Shifeng's premeditated murder is Liu Xin, which is also clear from the evidence. Look at the timeline of the conflict between Liu Xin and Chen Shifeng.

20 16 In the early morning of August 26th, when Liu Xinran walked out of Chen Shifeng's house, he called for help in Japanese, so his neighbor called the police. Liu Xin's arm was scratched and his mobile phone was taken away.

On August 3rd1,there was a serious conflict between them at Chen Shifeng's home. Chen Shifeng cut her wrist with a knife and threatened Liu Xin to get back together. Liu Xin wanted to call the police and the mobile phone was taken away for the second time.

On September 1, Liu Xin sent a message to Jiang Ge: "He threatened to cut my wrist with a knife yesterday and asked me to stay. I'm going crazy with fear. It's almost suffocating to think of it now. I am afraid that if I leave my aunt's shop now, I am afraid that he will suddenly appear with a knife and die with me. I have never been so desperate. "

On September 1 day, Liu Xin and Chen Shifeng sat down to chat and cry under the mediation of a part-time boss in a Chinese restaurant. Liu Xin borrowed/kloc-0,000,000 yen from Chen Shifeng, and Chen Shifeng changed its strategy and gave up violence to force Liu Xin to reunite.

On September 15, Chen Shifeng sent moon cakes and Lycium barbarum, and Liu Xin picked them up in the research room.

10 12 On Wednesday, Chen Shifeng gave a birthday present and exchanged it for 10000 yen.

Wednesday 10, 19, chicken wings with coke. (unconfirmed)

201165438in06+151October 2nd, Wednesday, Liu Xin fixed working day, Chen Shifeng blocked Liu Xin at home and blocked the cat's eye when ringing the doorbell. The motive is unknown.

16: 20, Liu Xin returned the key to Chen Shifeng's house after going out, although the washing machine and refrigerator were still at Chen Shifeng's house, and his parting attitude was firm. After that, Chen Shifeng followed Liu Xin and told him how painful he was recently, but Liu Xin ignored him.

16: 48, on the tram, Chen Shifeng threatened Liu Xin to get back together by spreading intimate photos and videos and contacting Liu Xin's parents. Liu Xin didn't agree.

18:00 10, Liu Xin pointed to his colleague Xiao Lin and said, this is the person I like. Chen Shifeng left without saying anything.

At about 18, Chen Shifeng appeared in the Dadong Culture Research Office. The prosecution speculated that the fruit knife, the toolbox left by the research room and the fragments of the handle left by the crime scene belonged to the same knife.

19: 04, Chen Shifeng WeChat: If you get along with him (Kobayashi), I will be desperate. "

19: 35, Chen Shifeng made an appointment with Liu Xin to meet at school the next day, which successfully let Liu Xin off guard.

2 1: 44, Chen Shifeng put on contact lenses, Chen Shifeng took his replacement clothes and knives, left the apartment by taking the stairs, walked to the station two stops away and took the bus. Outside 7 1 1, Liangen Station, he put on a mask and bought a bottle of whisky. He bought the electronic ticket in cash instead of the watermelon card that would leave a record.

At 22: 57, Chen Shifeng arrived at East MCC Station and stayed near the overpass at the entrance of the middle school affiliated to Meiji University for more than half an hour, which was the only way for Liu Xin to go home.

At 23: 09, Chen Shifeng and Liu Xin started to communicate on WeChat, and Chen Shifeng used "". . . ","desperate to come back ",to explain that a homicidal" if you get along with him (Xiao Lin), I will be desperate ",even if the knife has been brought in the body, people have been ambushed, and Chen Shifeng has concealed his murder.

12 at 23: 00, Liu Xin WeChat Jiangge said, "Wait for me, I'm so scared", even though I knew Jiangge would have to wait for her for more than 50 minutes.

Around 23: 30 (note: there is no time for WeChat photos collected by the police)

Liu Xin: I believe you can do it well, but I don't want you to do anything for me.

Liu Xin: What happened between us should be regarded as an episode in life. We all learn from each other.

23: 3 1

Chen Shifeng (pronunciation, translated version, non-original): I also want to adjust my mood, but my heart hurts more and more. I dream about you every night and want to forget you, but I can't. I expected you to respond to me, but I didn't expect you to have a cold face. I really don't want you to be so indifferent. My pain will never end.

(Note: Chen Shifeng can't hear the tram, but there is a tram in the voice background. It's nearly early morning, and Chen Shifeng is not at home, which is a very dangerous signal. )

(Note: Liu Xin denied hearing voices in the transcript, claiming that he had listened for several days, but the police photos at10.3 165438+9: 00 proved that he had heard voices. )

Liu Xin: Then I won't give you a cold face in the future. You can recover slowly, but don't threaten me again. You threaten me, and I will only give you a bad face involuntarily.

Liu Xin: Not giving you a cold face doesn't mean that we will make up. This is the premise.

(Note: Liu Xin responded to the key word in the voice at that time: indifference)

23: 00 to 12: 00 pm

Chen Shifeng: How are you getting along with him?

Liu Xin: This is my privacy.

At 23: 38, Chen Shifeng left the ambush site and went to ouchi's apartment.

At this point, Chen Shifeng made up his mind to kill Liu Xin.

At 23: 57, Liu Xin changed trains at Shinjuku Station, and there was a long interval between trams at night. Presumably, Liu Xin listened to the sound carefully at this time and found that there was a tram in the background. Chen Shifeng's family couldn't hear the tram, indicating that Chen Shifeng was not at home at this time; "If you get along with him, I will be desperate"+"How far have you progressed with him"+Chen Shifeng is not at home, and Liu Xin has reason to "be afraid that Chen Shifeng will ambush somewhere", so he sent five WeChat messages in succession, asking Jiangge to go directly to the A3 exit.

1October 2 165438+23: 57.

Liu Xin: You go to the subway near our house.

Liu Xin: It's the mouth in front of the barbecue shop.

Liu Xin: I know the exit is Exit 3. I'm used to it.

Liu Xin: In case you go to another exit and go the wrong way.

Jiangge: OK.

Jiangge: a3

Jiangge: I know.

What if I go to the other exit and go wrong again? If you are wrong, you are wrong. What can you do? )

Liu Xin actually felt the danger, but he didn't call the police or remind Jiangge. Because he didn't see Chen Shifeng after he left the station, he let his guard down. He also felt that with Jiangge's company, even if Chen Shifeng was nearby, he should not dare to make a difference and help Jiangge make this decision irresponsibly.

May have to answer one more question: Why did Chen Shifeng premeditated to kill Liu Xin, and Jiang Ge was killed in the end?

Chen Shifeng is waiting on the platform on the third floor of ouchi apartment.

Chen Shifeng is waiting at the platform on the third floor of Dani Apartment, about 10 meter away from the intersection where Liu Xin and Jianggehui will appear. He opened the door downstairs, walked up or ran up the 16 steps, and then crossed the 8-meter corridor. When he opens the car door, Chen Shifeng's reaction time may only be 20 seconds, so it is difficult for him to make a rational decision.

This kind of environment is very different from Chen Shifeng's original plan and the original ambush site. He was completely unprepared. After killing someone here in Tianqiao, he can escape calmly, then take Liu Xin's mobile phone and wallet, pretend to rob, and destroy knives and clothes. Even if he is caught later, I'm afraid the police can't even determine Chen Shifeng's motive for killing, because Jiangge doesn't know what happened at all. This is a perfect murder.

The initial ambush site

Liu Xin and Jiangge suddenly appeared in the field of vision, which was not in Chen Shifeng's plan.

First of all, it is impossible for Chen Shifeng to kill Liu Xin in front of Jiangge, because there will be witnesses, and Jiangge will call the police for help. Even if he succeeds in killing Liu Xin, he won't run away. This is not Chen Shifeng's plan. In doing so, there is no need for careful planning.

Then, there is only about 20 seconds left for Chen Shifeng to think. Liu Xin and Jiangge ran fast or walked fast, which made Chen Shifeng feel or misunderstand that he had been discovered. However, if Liu Xin calls the police, the crime of coercion is a criminal offence, and it is likely to be repatriated and its future will be ruined. He can't accept it at all. From his point of view, he can only be "forced" to kill.

Finally, if we kill Jiangge in the back first, and then kill Liu Xin in the door, the plan can still be completed. He seems to have a little chance. His primary goal is to cover his mouth and not let Liu Xin in the door find out. For Jiangge, he is naturally determined to kill.

He chose to follow up from the third floor. Maybe he can't catch the door. Anyway, he covered Jiangge's mouth from behind, but now he overestimates his ability and doesn't know what to do. Jiangge also "knocked hard" and rang the doorbell for help. Liu Xin found out. In the end, it took Chen Shifeng at least 1 min 37 seconds to bring down Jiangge. Jiangge was "sad" before he was fatally injured.

Jiangge was attacked from behind and pushed to the door, judging from the position where the food in his right hand fell.

The round table was originally a very relaxed talk show, and Professor Li Meijin had complete freedom of speech, even if her views were wrong.

However, when her remarks were used by Liu Xin's supporters, which seriously damaged Jiangge's reputation, Professor Li Meijin did not read the detailed trial report carefully to clarify and correct his views. On the contrary, it's even more regrettable that she fell to the Liu Xin camp because she consciously suffered cyber violence from Jiangge's mother's supporters, fully accepted Liu Xin's supporters and made more irresponsible remarks in Weibo.

Li Meijin fully accepted the story of Liu Xin supporters.

Interacting with the "famous" @ Lengshu actually agrees with his analysis.

So far, Professor Li Meijin has not apologized for his remarks, which is really regrettable.